 |
| Pictured is the basilica next to Mission Dolores, facing an elegant palm-lined street. San Francisco's Mission neighborhood takes its name from Mission Dolores, founded in 1776. |
|
![]() |
| |
| A row of Victorian "painted ladies" borders San Francisco's Alamo Square Park. |
|
Note: The AAG is pleased to be holding its 2007 Annual Meeting April 17-21 in the city of San Francisco. To highlight some of the fascinating aspects of the city, the Local Arrangements Committee (co-chaired by Nancy Wilkinson of San Francisco State University and Scott Mensing of the University of Nevada - Reno) will sponsor a series of newsletter articles on the San Francisco area. The following piece briefly introduces one of the city's defining characteristics--its many neighborhoods.
Hills and Valleys
San Francisco is a hilly place, which also makes it a city of valleys. There are, in fact, forty-three official hills, though a few stretch the concept. This topography has much to do with the patchwork character of San Francisco's neighborhoods, of which, depending on who counts, there are more than 100. If anything, the hill-valley-neighborhood relation is made obvious in place names: Pacific Heights, Russian Hill, Nob Hill, Telegraph Hill, Potrero Hill, Twin Peaks, Noe Valley, Cole Valley, Hayes Valley, Visitacion Valley. An unusual meeting of natural form and human endeavor makes San
Francisco's neighborhoods nearly iconic. The city has fifteen identifiable street grids,
a number of which were draped over the city's hills, rather than wound around them to lessen grades. This resulted in a network of unparalleled public views across the city, especially from several parks, including Alamo Square and Alta Plaza. Some of these parks exist because, being at the tops of hills, they were on inaccessible and not particularly valuable land, until Hallidie tested his cable car system in 1873. San Franciscans have been fighting to protect their hilltop views for more than half a century, and this is reflected in the built form of a number of the city's neighborhoods. The landmark urban design element in the city's general plan, for instance, dictates that shorter buildings be built at the base of hills and taller buildings at the tops, to prevent San Francisco's topography from being flattened.
Building height restrictions do more than preserve views and valleys. They also help to protect the historic character of many of the city's neighborhoods by reducing land value, and thus limiting the incentive to replace existing Edwardian houses, for instance, with modern condos. San Francisco is a preservation-minded city and has established seventeen formal historic and conservation districts.
The shopping street is central to every major neighborhood in the city, and each lends to its community a particular feel. Most residents' daily needs are met by a trip to San Francisco's version of the high street. Residents are intensely concerned with preserving the character of these streets, from which chain stores are largely absent. Legislation has allowed several neighborhoods to ban larger chains; in others, the number of certain
businesses (especially restaurants and bank branches) is limited to ensure a diversity of functions along the street.
Around the San Francisco Hilton
Despite its topography, San Francisco is an eminently walkable city, and certainly the best way to visit its neighborhoods is on foot (or bicycle). San Francisco is one of three cities in 2006 to be rated "gold level" for bike-friendliness by the League of American Cyclists). The weather in April is mild, but it can be variable, so rain gear is advisable. Though a source of frustration for some, MUNI, the city's bus and light rail system, is also a generally reliable and convenient way to get around.
The AAG's conference hotel, the Hilton San Francisco, is situated in the heart of the city's theater district and at the edge of several markedly different areas. Just to the northeast is Union Square, San Francisco's primary shopping district, and one of the ritziest in the country. The square itself was recently renovated and is well-used, though many consider its design a failure. Much of the area is part of a significant historic district that stretches to Market Street, where department stores, hotels, and luxury housing are being poured into newly rehabilitated buildings. Union Square is also known for its small, private art galleries. Many are open to the public, although they are sometimes hidden in
upper stories. Up-slope from the Hilton,
Nob Hill is old San Francisco money and
power, embodied in the Pacific Union
Club (housed in a mansion built by silver
baron James Flood), Grace Cathedral, and
the Fairmont and Mark Hopkins Hotels, all
accessible by the Powell Street Cable Car.
In the opposite direction, and of opposite
character, the Tenderloin is nearly immediately
west and south of the hotel. It is a
gritty neighborhood of residential hotels,
old apartment buildings, and a concentration
of inexpensive Indian, Pakistani, and
Vietnamese eateries. Much of the area
retains skid row qualities, but real estate
agents and a few locals have started to refer
to its northern edge as Lower Nob Hill and
I have recently heard the phrase "Trendyloin."
Rezoning in the mid 1980s saved
much of the Tenderloin from becoming an
extension of downtown, and it has resisted
gentrification longer than most other
neighborhoods.
Ethnic Neighborhoods
That San Francisco has no majority
ethnic population is reflected in its many
thriving ethnic neighborhoods. Grant
Avenue, San Francisco's oldest, joins two
distinct areas. Chinatown, which is both
a tourist attraction and one of the densest
neighborhoods in the country, is also the
oldest Chinatown in the U.S. and a place
of immense cultural richness. North
Beach, the birthplace of the beat generation,
is no longer at the water's edge.
Established during the Civil War by Italian
immigrants, many of whom were fishermen,
it is now full of Italian restaurants
and cafes and is known for its nightclubs
and bars.
Japantown lies a mile directly west of
the conference hotel. Though small in
area, it holds the largest concentration of
Japanese businesses and cultural institutions
in California, and perhaps the U.S.
Its focus is the Japan Center, a good
example of bad mid-twentieth century
architecture. Inside the five acre complex
is an oddly genuine mix of restaurants,
shops, and bars that even surprises locals.
Japantown is cheek-by-jowl with the
Fillmore, an African American neighborhood
rent apart by the city's
Redevelopment Agency in the 1960s with
wholesale urban renewal and the
construction of the Geary Expressway.
Once the "Harlem of the West," there are
plans to revive at least some of its cultural
heritage, which includes a once influential
jazz scene. It is home to several well
known music venues, including the
Fillmore and John Lee Hooker's Boom
Boom Room. Further west and a block
south of Geary, Clement Street in the
Inner Richmond has become a second, and
to some the real Chinatown, because there
are few tourists.
Near the center of the city lies the
expansive and largely Latino Mission.
Long a working class neighborhood of
immigrants, community organizations, and
artists, with a mix of production, distribution,
and repair businesses, the bohemian
Mission was hit hard by the dot-com
boom. "Live/work" loft housing, industrial
conversions, and gentrification have
pushed out many residents and businesses.
However, it remains a dynamic neighborhood
of burrito joints, upscale restaurants,
alternative art spaces, and ethnic mom and
pop stores. It is also the center of a vocal
and effective grass roots activism that has
struggled against rampant gentrification.
"Alternative" Neighborhoods
San Francisco has long been a city of the
"other." Though beatniks and hippies have
long gone, two neighborhoods in particular
remain mainstays of counter-culture life.
The Haight, or Haight-Ashbury, is really
two neighborhoods, Lower Haight and Upper Haight. The latter is famed as the
epicenter of the hippie movement, but is
now a destination for trend-minded youth
looking for shoes, bags, second hand
clothes, and the odd plastic robot figurine.
Yet the Upper Haight, nestled between
Buena Vista and Golden Gate Parks, is also
an energetic community-oriented commercial
district where yuppies, street punks,
and long-time residents rub shoulders.
Closer to Market Street, the Lower Haight
is an edgier place of small bars, night clubs,
and DJ hangouts. At its eastern border, one
of the city's horrendous public housing
projects was leveled in the 1990s and
replaced with townhouses for very lowincome
residents. Passing south through
lovely Duboce Park, where dogs outnumber
people, takes you back to Market Street
and the Castro.
San Francisco's neighborhoods are
ever-changing, and the Castro is no
exception. Its cow pastures were suburbanized
in 1887 with the completion of
the Market Street Cable Railway. Known
as Eureka Valley it was first a Scandinavian
settlement that, by the 1930s, had become
a working class Irish neighborhood. Since
the end of the 1960s, it has been the focus
of gay life in San Francisco, if not the
world. Named for its main commercial
street, the Castro is as close to a twentyfour
hour neighborhood as San Francisco
gets. Though recently connected directly
to tourists at Fisherman's Wharf by the historic
F-Line street cars, it remains a deeply
rooted and vibrant community. In an act
of pride and defiance, the Twin Peaks, at
Castro and Market Streets, was the first
gay bar in San Francisco to have open
glass windows.
(Re-) Nascent Neighborhoods
San Francisco is in the middle of a
tremendous burst of construction, much of
it occurring in the South or Market
(SoMa), a district of many parts. While
SoMA retains a little of its industrial and commercial heritage, it has been largely
transformed in recent years. A loophole in
the city planning code allowed builders to
riddle SoMa with 2,378 upscale live/work
housing units in the six year period from
1997 to 2002. New residents and increased
land values displaced many businesses.
The eastern-half of SoMa is undergoing a
more comprehensive reformation, spurred
on by the adoption last year of the city
planning deparmtent's "Rincon Hill Plan."
Taking advantage of the removal of the
Embarcadero Freeway, the fifty-five-acre
area is sprouting ten towers in the 350 to
500 foot range that will add 3,900 housing
units adjacent to downtown. Nearby to
the west, a planning process is underway
that will result in an expanded Transbay
Terminal and another vertical neighborhood
of 4,500 housing units. "Starchitect"
Renzo Piano has indicated interest in
designing for that project what might be
the tallest building west of Chicago.
South beyond SoMa and mostly below
China Basin Channel, lies the 315-acre
Mission Bay redevelopment area. After
decades of on-again, off-again planning
efforts and economic cycles, long idle rail
yards are being converted into 6,200
housing units and millions of square feet of
commercial, retail and hotel space. Mission
Bay is intended to be a center for bioscience
activities, and the University of
California-San Francisco?s new campus,
now open but still under construction, will
be its focus.
San Francisco is at once steeped in history
and a laboratory of urban change. Perhaps
the best, or most enjoyable, way to
develop a sense of this continually shifting
city is to explore its many neighborhoods.
Jasper Rubin
jasper_rubin@yahoo.com
To learn more about San Francisco and environs, visit http://www.placesonline.org/sitelists/nam/usa/california/SanFrancisco.asp.
|