Unit
1: How Does Industry Alter the Global Environment? Understanding
the Problem
Instructor's Guide to Activities |
Goal
The activities in Unit 1 (1) heighten the student's sense of place
and sense of connection to both local and global industrial activity, (2)
emphasize how industrial activity brings about local and global environmental
and social change, and (3) encourage students to interpret the changes
that technological advancement has produced throughout the world.
Learning Outcomes
After completing the activities associated with this unit, students
should:
-
understand how local industries can have regional and global environmental
impacts;
-
recognize their connections to global industry by virtue of the everyday
products they use;
-
develop a sense of place within the global community; and
-
recognize the ways that technology has transformed the life chances of
society and social culture.
Choice of Activities
It is neither necessary nor feasible in most cases to complete all
activities in each unit. Select those that are most appropriate for
your classroom setting and that cover a range of activity types, skills,
genres of reading materials, writing assignments, and other activity outcomes.
This unit contains the following activities:
Suggested Readings
The following readings accompany the activities for this unit.
Choose those readings most appropriate for the activities you select and
those most adequate for the skill level of your students.
-
Background Information to Unit 1 (all students should read)
-
Stern, Paul C., Oran R. Young, and Daniel Druckman. 1992. Human causes
of global change. In C. Stern, O. Young, and D. Druckman, eds. Global
environmental change. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press,
pp. 44-69.
-
Lynn, Walter R. 1989. Engineering our way out of endless environmental
crises. In Technology and Environment. Washington, D.C.:
National Academy Press, pp. 182-191.
-
Ausubel, Jesse H., et al. 1989. Technology and environment:
An overview. In Technology and Environment. Washington, D.C.:
National Academy Press, pp. 1-20.
BACK
| Activity 1.1: They Don't All
Have Smokestacks |
Goals
This activity facilitates discussion on the linkages among technology,
industry, and global change. Students consider industry in a broad sense
in a brainstorming session, identify the important local industries in
the community, and discuss how the local industry might have links to global
change.
Skills
-
identifying linkages between local and global scales
-
brainstorming
Material Requirements
Flip chart, notepad, or overhead projector to record information for
use in a later activity (optional)
Time Requirements
25 minutes
Tasks
This is a starter activity intended to get students thinking about
how industry in general is connected to global change and, more specifically,
how the businesses in your town or community are linked to global change.
Begin the activity by asking students the following questions:
1. What sorts of resources and what sorts of wastes are associated with
the following industries?
| tourism |
agriculture |
military/defense |
| film/entertainment |
construction (e.g., homes) |
fast food chains |
2. Can you name some industries with strong global impacts that have
the following characteristics:
-
High carbon or other trace gas emissions;
-
Large imports of resources from outside the region. (Be sure to note
the impacts of extraction. Are there any limitations to sustainable extraction
of resources? What are the implications for land degradation or biodiversity?);
and
-
Large exports of waste, hazards or other impacts?
After you have considered these questions briefly, ask the class to select
a local industry, preferably one that is important to the community and/or
to the families of the students in the classroom. Important industries
may the largest regional employer, a growth industry, a highly visible
industry because of a recent event, or an industry with a good reputation.
Ask students to brainstorm for a few minutes about the potential impacts
that the local industry has on the environment. Encourage them also
to think about the industry's activities in a global context. Does the
local industry affect the global environment? Where do the various
resources used in the industry come from? Where do the wastes go?
Note: You may want to record the information from the brainstorming
session on an overhead transparency, a chalkboard, or flip chart for use
in Activity 2.2.
BACK
| Activity 1.2: Shirts, Shoes,
and Watches |
Goals
Students examine local-to-global relationships by locating on a map
where various items they own have been produced. This map can be
further developed by adding the social and environmental conditions associated
with industries in various places (see Activity 2.5).
Skills
-
map reading
-
group collaboration
Material Requirements
-
a world map (a copy for an overhead transparency is provided in Supporting
Material 1.2)
-
colored thumb-tacks or markers
Time Requirements
20-25 minutes
Tasks
Place a world map at the front of the classroom. (Use the map
in Supporting Material 1.2 to create an overhead transparency or enlarge
it to create a poster-sized map.) Ask students to examine the label
on the shirt of the student sitting next to them as well as the label on
their own shoes and watches to determine where the items were made. Ask
each student (in a large class, select a few students) to use a color marker
or thumbtack to indicate the origin of each item, on the map. Use a different
color for each product (i.e., red for watches, blue for shoes, green for
shirts). Since many countries will be marked more than once with
the same color, the class should be able to see a distribution of the origin
of each item. Discuss the patterns visible on the map and ask students
to consider the relationship between their present location and the place
where the items were produced. Use the following questions to guide
the brief discussion:
1. What major regions of the world are not represented?
2. Why are watches made in the Philippines or shoes in southeast Asia?
3. What are the environmental, economic, and/or social consequences
of global markets?
4. Are you accountable for the environmental impacts resulting from
the production of items in other countries?
Alternative version
Instead of focusing on shirts, shoes, and watches, ask students to
determine where the food they eat in one day comes from. Students
will need to keep track of everything they eat during one day and investigate
where the products originate. Remind students that many packaged
foods list only the site of distribution on their labels -- not where the
products were actually made. You can ask students to prepare their own
maps to bring to class (provide Supporting Material 1.2 as a hand-out)
or use 15 minutes or more in class to map the locations as suggested above.
BACK
| Activity 1.3: Between Utopia
and Dystopia |
Goals
Students evaluate and respond to a film that graphically portrays the
environmental and social impacts of the modern, global, industrial culture.
Skills
-
qualitative data interpretation
-
film interpretation
Material Requirements
-
Student Worksheet 1.3
-
The film Koyaanisqatsi. Although this film is now out of print, copies
can still be obtained from university media collections or at local video
rental stores. The complete citation is Koyaanisqatsi: Life Out of
Balance, an IRE presentation produced and directed by Godfrey Reggio (Carmel,
CA: Pacific Arts Video Records), 1983; 87 minutes.
Time Requirements
2 class periods (100 minutes); 87 minutes for the film and additional
time (10-15 minutes) for discussion
Tasks
A thought-provoking conclusion to this unit is to watch the popular
underground film, Koyaanisqatsi by Godfrey Reggio. Depicting a view of
modern American society from the perspective of Native American ideals,
the film explores the largesse and imbalances of technologically driven
lifestyles to reveal the chaos and disorder that come from the mechanical
world view. Viewers will find the film to be intense with penetrating
minimalist music by Philip Glass; only one word is uttered throughout the
entire film -- a chanting of the film’s title “koyaanisqatsi.”
Beginning and ending with a slow motion observation of a rocket launch,
Koyaanisqatsi takes viewers on a ride across the sacred landscape of the
Hopi people in the American Southwest. The starkness and serenity
of an untouched land is then shattered with image after image of industrial
and urban settings. People are reduced to the scale of ants, their
buildings to piles of rubble. Flows of people, cars, and products
quicken and quicken with the tempo of the music reaching a crescendo when,
like the line by Marx, “all that is solid melts into air.”
From utopia to dystopia, the film provides a prophetic image a possible
future.
At the film’s conclusion, we are presented with five definitions of
the Hopi word koyaanisqatsi, including:
-
crazy life
-
life in turmoil
-
life out of balance
-
life disintegrating
-
a way of life that calls for another way of living.
The message of Koyaanisqatsi is clear: if we continue to let technology
overwhelm human-environment interactions, global change will occur in a
manner that is detrimental to all living things. The sacredness of the
land will be destroyed; settlements will outsize human scale; and our lives
will take place at a dizzying pace. It is clearly a crazy life that
calls for another way of living. Take at least two class periods
(50 minutes each) to show the film to the class. Instruct students
to pay particular attention to film’s main themes and to contemplate how
other groups of people unlike themselves might respond to the film’s message.
After the film is over, use the remaining time to ask the class the
following questions:
1. What is the meaning of the Hopi word “koyaanisqatsi”? (Five definitions
are provided near the end of the film.) Which definition do you think
has the most power or meaning in terms of this film? Why?
2. What is the film’s primary message? Do you agree or disagree
with it? Why?
3. Briefly speculate on responses to the preceding questions that might
be given by persons from several cultures or social groups. Examples
of these groups include the following:
| Libertarian party |
Buddhists |
| Greenpeace |
Republican or Democrats |
| Christians |
United Auto Workers |
4. Discuss the environmental images portrayed in the film in terms
of three or more of the following concepts:
| embodied energy |
entropy (see Unit 2) |
technological change |
| environmentalism |
modernity |
sustainable development |
BACK